What Is the Difference Between a Babysitter and a Childminder?

Not sure whether to choose a babysitter or a registered childminder? In this article, we clearly explain the differences — including pros and cons — so you can decide what works best for your family.

What Does a Babysitter Do, and What Does a Childminder Do?

A babysitter looks after your children in your own home, often on a flexible basis. This could be a neighbor, an experienced student, or a professional working via a platform like Carello. Babysitters are usually paid by the hour and no formal contracts are required. You can book a babysitter whenever you need one — occasionally or on a regular schedule. A childminder, on the other hand, typically provides care from their own home and looks after multiple children at once, although care can also take place in your home. Childminders are officially registered, work under the Dutch Childcare Act, and parents are eligible to apply for childcare benefits. The care is usually offered during daytime hours and includes structured routines, planned activities, and progress reports about your child’s development. Arranging care with a childminder is a more formal process than hiring a babysitter. You are considered an official employer, which means you take on administrative responsibilities such as drafting a contract, managing payroll, and arranging insurance. Childminders are also entitled to paid vacation days and continued salary during illness. This setup requires more planning and commitment from you as a parent.

Pros and Cons: What Suits Your Family Best?

A babysitter offers great flexibility and can often be available in the evenings or on short notice. Babysitters also tend to develop a personal bond with your child. Since care happens at your home, your child remains in a familiar environment, making separation easier. Plus, there’s no need to handle complex paperwork. However, there are a few things to consider. Babysitting does not qualify for childcare benefits, unlike care provided by a registered childminder. With Carello, many babysitters are students in or graduates of educational or childcare programs. This brings both peace of mind and flexibility. If you choose a childminder, you benefit from access to childcare subsidies. Childminders are often professionally trained and registered, ensuring your child is in capable hands. On the downside, childminders typically offer less flexibility in terms of hours and location, and since they care for multiple children, there may be less one-on-one attention for your child. In short, if you value flexibility and a personal approach, a babysitter is often the better choice. If financial support through childcare benefits is important to you, then a registered childminder may be more suitable. With Carello, you can quickly find a reliable babysitter that matches your family’s needs.